Feature articles

22 October 2020

OPINION: When will professional users of rodenticides wake up to the potential consequences of their actions?

Opinion| Rodenticide Resistance

Dr John Simmons, Acheta Consulting, writes about the consequences of not taking rodenticide resistance seriously following a CRRU statement about new survey results. 

guest-blog-john-simmons-rodenticide

As part of our site inspections our team of consultants carry out an independent review of the quality of service provided by the incumbent pest control contractor.

In recent months Acheta’s consultants have highlighted, on far too many occasions, the inappropriate use of rodenticides, often combined with no (or an inappropriate) Environmental Risk Assessment. We have had several instances where the incumbent contractor has been vociferous in accusing us of being over-the-top in our demands.

A press release today by the Campaign for Responsible Rodenticide Use (CRRU) completely vindicates the line that we have taken.

To quote CRRU chairman Dr Alan Buckle:

CRRU research finds 58% of professional pest controllers say they are “not very” or “not at all” concerned about resistance.

He continues, "Everyone connected with rodenticide use needs to wake up to this issue, pay attention to the information available and change the way they use anticoagulant rodenticides accordingly.

"The onus is squarely on rodenticide users to maximise their knowledge and make responsible fact-based decisions about control measures. This can start, of course, with using the CRRU Code of Best Practice, as the basis of control measures. Every time before rodenticide bait is laid, users should ask themselves, will this active ingredient work here against this pest?”

The cornerstone of the rodenticide stewardship regime is the Code of Best Practice for the use of rodenticides published by CRRU UK in early 2015.

Application of rodenticides according to the code will prevent unnecessary exposure of wildlife and other non-target animals and help deliver the objectives of the regime. The aim is to ensure that all users of professional-only rodenticide baits comply with the CRRU Code of Best Practice and to work with assurance schemes to bring standards into alignment with the CRRU UK Code of Best Practice.

One of the primary criticisms that we often level when reviewing pest control service is that, because of genetic resistance to the active ingredient(s) being employed, pest control contractors are using rodenticides that we suspect (or sometimes know) are unlikely to work. Such use often continues for a prolonged period, when a simple test would indicate whether resistance genes are present.

In many cases there has not even been any reference made by the contractor to the resistance map of the UK, a freely available reference source detailing the currently known resistance status throughout the UK.

New 2019-2020 survey results show not only that 74% of rats analysed carried a resistance gene but, of those studied, one-in-five had two different genes in widespread locations: County Durham, West and East Yorkshire, Greater Manchester, Merseyside, Dorset and on the West/East Sussex border.

I’ll leave Dr Buckle to summarise the potential repercussions if current practice doesn’t change:

“Quite what this means for the future of pest rodent control would be inadvisable speculation right now. But it’s certainly bad and CRRU is examining the potential implications and strategies as a matter of utmost importance.”

Make no mistake, the best we can perhaps expect is further restriction on anticoagulant rodenticide use, whilst the ultimate sanction could be the complete removal of anticoagulant rodenticides from the market.

In Acheta we will continue to highlight bad practice for the serious issue that it undoubtedly is. Indeed, in future we will tighten our assessment of whether we believe rodenticide use on any specific site is both legal and appropriate. We make no apologies for taking this line.

Dr John Simmons
Business Unit Director, Acheta Consulting Ltd
20th October 2020

Source: Acheta release

Highlights View all news

29 June 2021

Latest news

BPCA secures funding for 3D interactive simulator

BPCA is excited to announce that we have been successful in securing funding from the Ufi VocTech Trust, to support the development of an interactive 3D competency simulator for pest technicians.

Read more

17 June 2021

Latest news

UK government confirms plans to ban rodent glue boards completely

The UK government has issued details on the Glue Traps (Offences) Bill to crack down on “inhumane rodent traps”. In a government press release it states: “Glue trap

Read more

06 June 2021

Latest news

VIDEO: Happy World Pest Day 2021 #TechnicianTakeover

Once a year, (6 June) the whole pest management sector across the world seeks to increase public, government, and media awareness of the important role we all play in protecting public health.

Read more
Latest View all news

22 July 2021

Latest news

Join our new working group for member complaints

BPCA is reviewing its member complaints procedures and is looking for some members to get involved with a new complaints working group. BPCA Technical and Compliance Manager Natalie Bunga

Read more

22 July 2021

Latest news

VIDEO: Understanding pests in food businesses

Pests in food businesses can damage and contaminate food, causing economic loss and threatening public health. In this video Natalie looks at the main species you are likely the encounter, the

Read more

21 July 2021

Latest news

Five Years of Rodenticide Stewardship report published

A report of the UK Rodenticide Stewardship Regime’s work covering 2016 to 2020 has been published by the Campaign for Responsible Rodenticide Use. This feeds into a formal five-year review bei

Read more